02 December 2021The RCP and Neath

A Minor Political Disturbance

Keith Tucker

Considering the strong relationship that the town of Neath had with the Liberal Prime Minister David Lloyd George (he had been given the Freedom of the Borough when he visited the National Eisteddfod, held here in 1918), then it was maybe inevitable that Neath would return the Liberal coalition candidate Hugh Edwards at the 1918 election.

It was in February 1918 that the Representation of the People Act widened suffrage by abolishing practically all property qualifications for men and by enfranchising women over 30 who met minimum property qualifications; all men over 21 gained the vote in the constituency where they were resident.

The rise in popularity of socialism particularly in south Wales would, however, mean that from 1922 to the present day, Neath had remained a Labour stronghold returning the following candidates;

1922 - 1944 - William Jenkins, 1945 - 1964 - David James Williams,

1964 - 1991 - Donald Coleman, 1991 - 2015 - Peter Hain, 2015 - present - Christina Rees

It is usual in the main that a number of parties will table candidates in election contests.  Apart from the usual 'big gun' parties there have been, over the years, some surprising fringe factions appearing on the ballot paper.

(1929) - Unionist

(1983) - Computer Democrat

(1991) - a 'bumper' year

Local Labour Independent

Monster Raving Looney, when David Edward Sutch famously known by his stage    name 'Screaming Lord Sutch' stood. (sadly, he would commit suicide in 1999)

Barry Kirk stood as Captain Beany of the Bean Party

(1997) - Referendum

Legalise Cannabis, when the candidate was the notorious Welsh drug smuggler Howard Marks (Mr Nice)

(2001) - Pro Life Alliance

 Socialist Alliance

(2005) - Respect

(2010) - BNP (British National Party)


(2019) - Brexit

Most of these factions garnered only a handful of votes and candidates may only have stood for the reason of advertising their cause, or out of pure vanity.  However, possibly the most interesting challenge took place at the Neath By-Election of 1945 (caused by the death of William Jenkins in 1944) when one of the contenders was the Revolutionary Communist Party with their candidate Jock Haston.

The RCP was a British Trotskyist group formed in 1944 who were supporters of the political ideology and branch of Marxism developed by the Ukranian/Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky.  The south and west Wales coalfields held many supporters of the Communist Party, but loyalties waned when after June 1941 they supported the War effort and condemned unofficial strikes.  The vacuum thus created on the left gave an opportunity for the Trotskyists to exploit.  The Neath branch of the 'Anti-Labour Laws Defence Committee' was supported by local miners' lodges which gave the RCP the view that Neath was an area of advance Labour views.

Although they knew that they would not win the seat they saw the election as an opportunity to present their views to the public.  The Neath Guardian reported 'Jock Haston is an outstanding orator who answered all questions with good humour.'

From left to right: Anne Ward, Bill Davy, Sastry, John Lawrence, Heaton Lee, Ted and Jimmy Deane

The by-election was fought between the Labour Party, the RCP, and the Welsh Nationalist Party [now Plaid Cymru] with the Conservative and Liberal parties unrepresented because of a political truce.  However, there was a real fight between the RCP and the Communist Party (who were supporting Labour).  In a booklet 'Trounce the Trotskyists' Alun Thomas of the CP said that 'Trotskyists are a greater menace and far more dangerous than a Fascist paratrooper' a claim that he followed up with statements from the Moscow show trial of Nikolai Bukharin who was charged with conspiring to overthrow the Soviet state. The RCP exposed this as a frame up.  The RCP itself held 70 public meetings and distributed 30,000 leaflets at places of work.  A debate between Alun Thomas and Jock Haston at the Gwyn Hall was attended by 1,500 people.




Jock Haston in discussion outside the Neath election campaign headquarters on  Alfred Street near the Neath & District Auto Co. Ltd.

The results of the election were:

DJ Williams (Labour) - 30,847

W Samuel (Welsh Nationalist) - 6,290

Jock Haston (RCP) - 1.781

Even though the RCP were happy with the result, after all of this considerable effort the long term effect was small with only six new members joining the Neath branch.  This disappeared soon after the collapse of the RCP in 1949 following debates on the nature of the class struggles in Russia.

It seems that Haston's relations with DJ Williams were personally harmonious since later in 1949 Williams was instrumental in finding Haston a job with the National Council of Labour Colleges where he became a lecturer.  Following this he was educational director for the Electrical, Electronic, Telecommunications and Plumbing Union (EEPTU).


For all that it remains one of the many unique chapters in the history of Neath.


More detailed information on Jock Haston, the RCP and the Neath by-election of 1944 can readily be found through online searches.  


02 November 2021NEATH NEWS - 9th December 1910

Some of the things that were seen as interesting enough to report in 1910





The town of Neath developed around the castle and the church.  Bridge Street was the road in and Water Street the road out.  For centuries the main streets forming the town were High Street (now Old Market Street), Cattle Street, Wind Street and (from c1600) New Street.

In the early eighteenth century things started to change.  The Mackworths had arrived!  Their entrepreneurial schemes meant an influx of workers and the town expanded, initially along Water Street towards the Mera and along the Latt towards Llantwit.  The Mackworths brought with them many new industries which were mainly based in the Melincrythan area.  They also expanded the coal workings.  Coal was known to have been worked in the Neath area from at least the thirteenth century but not on the same scale.  The Abbey had developed pits and the Evans family of the Gnoll had held a monopoly of the trade near the town.  Now, under the Mackworths, new pits were opened.

                                           A Coal Mine near Neath c.1798                       British Library

Henry Penruddock Wyndham, a topographer from Salisbury, visited Neath on his second tour of Wales in 1777.  He was delighted with the industry he could see on either side of the River Neath and extending inland.  He espied copper works, tin works, iron works and coal pits and was very impressed.  However, his excitement was nullified by the appearance of Neath town.  He said that, unlike other new industrial towns that he had seen, such as Manchester and Liverpool, Neath had not built broad streets and grand buildings.  Instead, he commented that the housing for the most part consisted of 'miserable hovels' which compared unfavourably with those in the poorest English village.

Neath constricted by the river, church, castle and valley sides was never going to be a Manchester or a Liverpool, although the Mackworths no doubt played their part by supplying their workers with cheap housing and not investing in the structure of the town.

The river by 1781 when 'CG' visited the area was spanned by a single arch bridge described by him as 'perhaps one of the first pieces of architecture in the Kingdom.'  Another anonymous author, 'CC' just eight years later said that 'The bridge over Neath River has one half of its length built of wood, and the other half of stone….. It is in an infirm state and will probably soon be replaced by a new one.'

'CC' commented that the streets of Neath were well paved, but narrow. Fourteen years later when the Reverend John Evans of Bristol arrived (1803) the town was still described as having 'narrow and dirty streets with houses blackened by smoke.'  In fact, he went further and said that, 'a more uncomfortable or disgusting place, perhaps, can not be imagined.'  The Reverend Richard Warner of Bath (1798) spoke of houses which were 'ill-built and incommodious' and John Thomas Barber, a miniature portrait artist, arriving also in 1803 commented on the 'soil blackened with coal-works and rail-ways' (sic. tramways).

The Reverend Sir Thomas Gery Cullum’s remark (1811) about Neath about sums up the opinion of tourists.  He talked about the dismal smoking town of Neath and adds, 'I could have shut my eyes with pleasure when passing thro’ this Headquarters of Vulcan.'

The smoke from the manufactories was a huge problem.  It descended on the town and its environs for two-thirds of the year and must have had much the same effect as the London smog of the last century.  The smoke didn’t just stay for a few years – it must have been present for the best part of a century.  Margaret Martineau on her tour of Wales in 1824 wrote that at Neath comes 'the end of the beauties.  A thick smoke closed the scene and we drew in copper at every breath.'  Writing in 1861, Samuel Carter Hall, a London journalist and author, said that, 'Neath is now a town of smoke through which its rare and valuable antiquaries are all to often but barely seen.'


Samuel Carter Hall

Accommodation in the town varied.  The Mackworth Arms seems to have been the most popular although in 1801 a botanist, Thomas Martyn, said that 'the ceilings are low and most of the furniture old and dirty.'  On the other hand, Michael Faraday (1819) had no complaints and said that 'our Host … was very attentive.' Thomas Mytton and his sons, Henry and Thomas, stayed at the Ship and Castle in 1776 and stated that there was a very elegant assembly room.  Twenty years later, the Reverend Warner (1798) stayed commented that he was, 'attracted by the good-humoured face of the little fat landlord, Mr. Roteley.'  However, the ups and downs of these hostelries may be noted in the comments of two anonymous women from Norfolk (probably Mrs. Judith Beecroft and her daughter Laura) who were not impressed in 1827 when they wrote that the Ship and Castle 'did not promise much but it was the best inn.'  They also added that it was 'humble, dirty and dear.'

The wealth of Neath was due, not only to its industries but also to its position as a river port.  Colonel John Byng [a nephew of Admiral Byng] arrived in August 1787 and was taken on a tour of the shipbuilding yards, rope walks, iron forges and to Sir Herbert Mackworth’s shops and water engines.  Coal was king even in the eighteenth century and nearly every other industry depended on its availability.  The botanist Edward Donavon (1805) remarked that the works had received a temporary check due to the war but were now reviving.  He said that coal, apart from being exported and used in the works, was also sold locally in 'strikes' which he said was a measure peculiar to the area.  He also advocated stone coal which was sold in great quantities.  Stone coal burnt slow with little smoke and was used successfully for drying malt.


The castle at Neath was described by one topographer as 'the remains of the remains of a castle.'  Warner visited and remarked that 'one narrow piece of wall, which rises to a great height, and being unsupported by other parts of the building, threatens to crush the surrounding cottages on the first hurricane that shall happen.'   Henry Wigstead who came a year earlier than Warner noted that the castle was 'in a very ruinous state and at present appropriated to confine hogs and fatten in.'


Journal of a Tour Thro’ Part of South Wales 1776 - Thomas Mytton (Shropshire RO 1037/27/41)

A Tour through Monmouthshire and Wales 1777 - Henry Penruddock Wyndham

A Tour in South Wales 1781 - C.G   (NLW MS 14978B)

The Torrington Diaries - 1787. ed C.B.Edwards (1954)  - Colonel John Byng             

CCs Tour in Glamorgan (Gentleman’s Magazine) - (Glamorgan Historian Vol.2) (1789)      

Remarks on a Tour to North and South Wales in the year 1797 - Henry Wigstead   (Cardiff Library)

Second Tour through Wales 1798 - Reverend Richard Warner   

Diary of Thomas Martyn 1801 - (NLW MS 1340C)         

Letters Written During a Tour of South Wales 1803 - Rev. John Evans (Cardiff Ref. L:942.986(045)EVA)

Descriptive Excursions through South Wales in the year1804 & the Four Preceding Summers (vol 2). - Edward Donovan                  

Journals of Reverend Sir Thomas Gery Cullum 1811- (NLW)

Michael Faraday 1819(Michael Faraday in Wales) 1972

Travel diary of Margaret Martineau 1824 - Hampshire R.O. Ref. 83M93/21

Two anonymous women from Norfolk - 1827 (Cardiff CL 2.325)

The Book of South Wales and the Wye - Samuel Carter Hall (1860)


View All Stories

sitemap | cookie policy | privacy policy | accessibility statement